5 Best Waterproof Eyeliners

Eyeliners are known to be a makeup kit use in bringing attention to one’s eyes. It helps individuals to create a variety of different looks as it is essential for all makeup routine. Eyeliners are known to come in various forms and formulas as some help to reduce smudge, creating an undesirable eye and run down one’s face.

Eyeliners are specially made to brighten the eyes, give a polished look to one’s makeup, and define one’s features. So many eyeliners exist in the market, making it difficult to make a selection. But everyone loves something that can create a captivating look, crisp lines, and that is easy to apply. These eyeliners are known to come in different forms and have different staying power.

In this article, we would be looking at some of the types of eyeliner and applicators, buying tips to consider before buying waterproof eyelinersthe best selection in the Indian market currently along with FAQs.

Types of waterproof eyeliners applicators

Eyeliners come in different forms and formulae, so as the brushes used in the application of these eyeliners. The eyeliners applicators include

The felt tip applicators 

The felt tip pen applicators are one of the most favorite types of applicator because it is y to use as that of the pencil. With the felt tip applicator, one can create a beautiful and thick line that is dependent on the angle of the applicator, and the pressure one applied.

The brush applicators 

This applicator works like nail polish. The brush applicator is easily attached to the paints and lid eyeliner. The brush applicators can be used to create unique thicknesses or to create a different line.

Pen-like applicator

This pen-like applicator is another unique type of applicator. It is mostly suitable for professionals and individuals vast in the business of making up.

Types of Eyeliners

Several eyeliners exist in the market with their different pros and cons. Here are some common types of eyeliners in the market

Liquid eyeliner

The liquid eyeliner is designed to leave a well-defined line. Professional makeup artists mostly use this. The liquid eyeliner gives one that exotic look and variety of looks. With liquid eyeliners, one can create different looks that you desire. 

The liquid form of eyeliner is known to last longer, and that is dependent on the quantity of the eyeliner you apply. The eyeliner comes with a brush applicator to give a more defined line. It comes in black and brown ink and allows one to capture unique designs like a cat-eye or wing.

The shortcoming of this type of eyeliner is that it takes time to become perfect in the application of it. It can also be affected by eye water and rain. It is also noted that some formula of liquid eyeliners bleeds and crack off easily.

Gel eyeliners 

The gel eyeliner is comparatively new eyeliners formulae in the Indian market. This type of eyeliner comes in a pot and a separate applicator brush. The difference of the gel eyeliner with the liquid eyeliners is that it is more flexible as it can easily be blended. Remember to always clean the applicator brush after making use of the brush. With the brush type, one can make unique designs such as flared lines, thick and bold lines. Gel eyeliner lasts for a long time without cracking or flaking.

Pencil eyeliner

The pencil eyeliner is the most commonly used and available one in the market. It is the conventional one and the least expensive, among others. The eyeliner is not as intense as the gel or liquid types. One good thing about this type of eyeliner is that it comes in numerous colors and variety. The shortcoming is that it easily breaks, tug, and not often smooth. 

Cream eyeliners

The cream eyeliner type is also suitable for first-timers as it is easy to apply since it blends easily. The shortcoming of this type of product is that they easily rub off and smudge.

Guides in Buying a suitable Waterproof Eyeliners

Buying eyeliners to most people is by trial and error, and this is dependent on one’s skin texture, age, and tone. Here are some factors one needs to consider when making a selection for a good liner.

Eyeliner formula

Eyeliners come with a different formula, and they are not made equal. It is important to go for an eyeliner with a high pigment content as it covers better. When we talk about high pigmentation, we are looking at how easy it is to apply the eyeliner to give smooth and crisp results.

Past Reviews

Make sure to read about past reviews online. This helps you to ascertain a good product from a bad one. Bad or inferior eyeliners get smudge easily, flake, crack, and rub-off

Eyeliner Sensitivities

The sensitivity of the eyeliner should also be noted. For individuals with sensitive eyes, skin, or wears eye contact, it will be important to select eyeliner without any harsh chemicals. Go for a product made specifically for those individuals with sensitive skin. An example is the water-based formulas. 

Stay power

No one wants a product that washes out or fades off easily. Ascertain if the product feather into the creases of your skin or bleed.

Make sure you check to see if it flakes, appears patchy or cracks before purchasing. For a good eyeliner, it should dry quickly on an average of 30 seconds and should not smudge when you rub it over with your finger.


Determine what type of eyeliner applicator that you will be needing. If you are looking for a precision tip, then you should go for a felt tip or marker brush.

Opaque and smudge-proof

A good eyeliner should be fully pigmented and transfers resistant. Make sure that the eyeliner is fully opaque and smudge-proof. This will help to keep control in our hands.

With this, every sharp line made or smudge is deliberate. With an opaque and smudge-proof eyeliner, one can be sure that the flawless eyeliner is intact.


Confirm if the eyeliners are free from some harmful chemicals. Go for eyeliners that will not irritate you.


Price is another important factor to consider when buying an eyeliner. It would be expensive to pay 500 or more for a small eyeliner, except it is of superior quality.

The shape of the eyes

The shape of the eyes also influences the quality and thickness of the eyeliner to apply or purchase. Consult your makeup artist to explain the different types of eyeliner that can suit your eye’s shape.

Top 5 Waterproof Eyeliners

1. L’Oreal Paris Super Liner Gel Intenza Eyeliner 

Loreal Paris offers all the range of make right from lipsticks, mascaras, liners, and much more. Loreal Paris has introduced this super Gel-based eyeliner that lasts up to 36 hours. Yes! You heard it right. Now no need to reapply your eyeliner again and again.

It is effortless to apply just like a pencil eyeliner, and it stays for a long period, just like any good gel-based eyeliner. It comes with a very nice and durable applicator that makes it very easy to use. 

PROS (What we liked)
  • It is waterproof so it won’t smudge, making it smudge-proof
  • It is highly pigmented 
  • It lasts up to 36 hours
  • You can easily apply it with the applicator provided
  • It does not fade away
  • It dries quickly and easy to remove
CONS (What we didn’t like)
  • No negative points observed so far.

2. Colorbar Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner 

Colorbar liquid eyeliner is a waterproof eyeliner that is suitable for most skin types. It is long-lasting and does not crack, smudge, peel, or flake. 

The eyeliner is known to come with a high definition and flexible felt tip applicator. With this applicator, a stroke is enough to give a thick line. It is suitable for sensitive eyes, waterproof, and individuals wearing contact lenses.

PROS (What we liked)
  • The eyeliner is matte and highly pigmented 
  • The product is water-resistant
  • It lasts for a long time
  • It is suitable for sensitive eyes
  • The eyeliner does not crack, smudge or flake
CONS (What we didn’t like)
  • The quantity for the price is low.

3. Maybelline Hyper Glossy Liquid Liner 

The Maybelline hyper glossy liner comes in a liquid form with a great staying power. It can last for 24 hours without falling off or cracking.

It helps to give one thick and bold line. With this eyeliner, one can highlight the eyes all day. The Maybelline eyeliner is easy to apply and a popular brand among most women.

PROS (What we liked)
  • The liner gives one a hyper glossy experience.
  • It comes with an intense black color and a high shiny finishing. 
  • It is easy to apply as it creates a bold and sleek line with ease.
  • The product is smudge-proof 
  • It is intensely pigmented. It comes with 24-hour wear.
  • The eyeliners brush comes with fine bristles that are easy to use
  • The product is spill-proof since it comes in a good package.
  • It is travel-friendly
CONS (What we didn’t like)
  • No negative points observed so far.

4. ADS Jet Black 2 In 1 Waterproof Black Color Eyeliner 

ADS jet black is a two in one long-lasting eyeliner. It is waterproof and ensures the precision of a liquid liner. The eyeliner is suitable for everybody’s tone and occasion.

It helps to create a three-dimension look. It gives a sensual and sexy definition. It is a colorful waterproof liner, low burden, ultralight, easy to spread, and smudge-proof.

PROS (What we liked)
  • It can double up as an eyeshadow 
  • The eyeliner gel is a great option
  • It is long-lasting
  • It is a 2 in 1 gel liner and eye powder
  • The eyeliner is easy to spread
  • It is ideal for all occasion and outing
CONS (What we didn’t like)
  • The brush is a bit hard to use

5. Swiss Beauty Eyeliner Pen 

The Swiss Beauty Pro Super Black is a good option for anyone that wishes to redefine their eyes to perfection. It comes with 18 hours of stay time and does not fall off easily. It is smudged less and does not smear. 

One great thing about this product is the applicator that it comes with. The applicator is easy to use and gives a great design. It is a pen-type design making it simple and easy to define the contours of one’s eyes. 

PROS (What we liked)
  • The eyeliner is waterproof
  • It is smudge-proof and non-transferable 
  • It dries quickly and long-lasting
  • The eyeliners help to highlight the shape of one’s eyes
  • The product comes with an easy to use applicator
  • It comes in a pen-type design that makes it easy to define the eyes contours
  • It does not easily get smeared 
CONS (What we didn’t like)
  • The eyeliner gets dried up quickly when opened, which is not good.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. How do I remove waterproof eyeliner?

Waterproof eyeliners are not easy to remove like other types of eyeliners. One will need a makeup remover to remove the waterproof eyeliners

2. Can I wear eyeliner with eye extension?

You can, but it is better to use eyeshadow to line the eyes rather than using a typical eyeliner. But if you still wish to use an eyeliner with an eye extension, then the liquid, pencil and cream liners should be avoided because it can be risky with eyelashes extensions. Also, oil-based liquid eyeliners are not also recommended since the oil cans easily weigh down the lashes. This may lead to the loss of the extension.

3. What kind of applicator can I use?

One can use different types of applicator as it is dependent on the make of the eyeliner.

4. How long does it take for waterproof eyeliners to dry?

Waterproof eyeliner dries in seconds.

5. What is the difference between Waterproof, Water-Resistant, and Smudge-Proof?

Waterproof eyeliners stay on all day while smudge proofs are difficult for certain kinds of liners such as pencil and gel liners.


In selecting the right waterproof eyeliner, one needs to take cognizance of the skin texture and experience. If the eyeliner is smudging as a result of your skin type or wrinkles, then you need to select something that can stay longer.

Endeavor to read vast reviews and check-up with your makeup artist to determine the best eyeliners from this list. This will help you to determine the one that will suit your skin texture and gives you fuller eyes. With a good liner, one can create different looks and create the precision look that is needed.

Make the right selection and stand out from the crowd.

Swati Jain

Swati’s forte lies in managing content, most of it that’s on reviews.in. She is a multitasking mother and despite her hectic schedule finds time to review and write amazing content about baby products. You will always find her working either creating impartial content for reviews.in and fulfilling motherly duties.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: